2004 · Week 16

Final

Giants

New York

QB Eli Manning

22·23

Bengals

Cincinnati

QB Jon Kitna

Paul Brown Stadium · outdoors · fieldturf · 24°F · wind 3mph

Closing spread

CIN -6.5

Total

46.5

Model margin

+7.9est.

CIN perspective

Push chance

None

half-point line — cannot push

Win probability

  • Bengals
  • Giants

How each play moved the game.

Bengals winsGiants wins

Matchup

Where the edges are

Season-long league percentiles for both sides, mirrored. The saturated side of a lopsided row holds the edge.

Giantsedge mapBengals
  • -0.028EPA / play-0.059
  • 43.5%Success rate43.2%
  • -0.017EPA / dropback-0.020
  • -0.044EPA / rush-0.114
  • 8.2%Explosive rate8.8%
  • 29.5%Third-down rate40.8%
  • 53.1%Red-zone TD rate53.2%
  • 1.65Points / drive1.40
  • 2.2%Turnover rate3.1%
  • +0.008EPA / play allowed-0.048

Bar length is league percentile, already oriented so longer is better. The saturated side of a lopsided row holds the edge; rows within ~12 points are washed as even.

The rivalry

All square 3–3 since 1999

Meetings average 39.8 points. CIN are 4-2 ATS in the series.

Previous meetings
SeasonMatchupScoreWinner
2024 · W6CIN @ NYG17–7CIN
2020 · W12NYG @ CIN19–17NYG
2016 · W10CIN @ NYG20–21NYG
2012 · W10NYG @ CIN13–31CIN
2008 · W3CIN @ NYG23–26NYG

Possession by possession

How it unfolded

Every drive: who had the ball, how far it went, how it ended, and the score as it settled.

Drive-by-drive log
BallStartPlaysYardsResultNYG–CIN
NYGQ1 15:00622Punt0–0
CINQ1 11:4239Punt0–0
NYGQ1 9:4834Punt0–0
CINQ1 8:54746Touchdown0–7
NYGQ1 5:26413Punt0–7
CINQ1 4:073-1Punt0–7
NYGQ1 2:401157Touchdown7–7
CINQ2 12:49631Field goal7–10
NYGQ2 9:46859Field goal10–10
CINQ2 5:2273Turnover10–10
NYGQ2 3:13949Field goal13–10
CINQ3 15:00816Turnover on downs13–10
NYGQ3 11:21734Field goal16–10
CINQ3 7:361058Touchdown16–17
NYGQ3 1:21849Field goal19–17
CINQ4 12:38842Turnover19–17
NYGQ4 8:20523Field goal22–17
CINQ4 5:1536Punt22–17
NYGQ4 4:03516Punt22–17
CINQ4 2:05624Touchdown22–23
NYGQ4 0:4410Turnover22–23
CINQ4 0:2800End of half22–23

Box score

Individual performances

Giants

Passing

PlayerC/AttYdsTDINT
Eli Manning19/3720101

Rushing

PlayerCarYdsAvgTD
Tiki Barber221095.01
Ron Dayne6335.50

Bengals

Passing

PlayerC/AttYdsTDINT
Jon Kitna20/3218621

Rushing

PlayerCarYdsAvgTD
Rudi Johnson19311.61
Jon Kitna2147.00
Kenny Watson273.50
T.J. Houshmandzadeh177.00

Where this game is likely to land

  • Model
  • Smooth (normal)
  • Betting line

Probability of each final margin. Football scoring clusters — the spikes at 3 and 7 are real, and a smooth model misses them.

line +6.52.9%5.6%7.1%3.2%5.0%3.4%3.4%2.7%

Positive margins favour Bengals; negative favour Giants.

Half-point at risk

4.98%

outcomes that flip if the line moves 0.5

Model home win

69.6%

Expected total

43.4est.

Model

Where the number comes from

Each component is additive, in points of expected margin.

  • Team ratings (opponent-adjusted EPA)+1.04
  • Home-field advantage+2.56
  • Quarterback adjustment+4.39
  • Rest differential-0.08
  • Expected margin+7.91