2004 · Week 12 · Division

Final

Browns

Cleveland

QB Kelly Holcomb

48·58

Bengals

Cincinnati

QB Carson Palmer

Paul Brown Stadium · outdoors · fieldturf · 38°F · wind 13mph

Closing spread

CIN -6

Total

37.5

Model margin

+2.3est.

CIN perspective

Push chance

3.1%est.

the line sits on a key number

Win probability

  • Bengals
  • Browns

How each play moved the game.

Bengals winsBrowns wins

Matchup

Where the edges are

Season-long league percentiles for both sides, mirrored. The saturated side of a lopsided row holds the edge.

Brownsedge mapBengals
  • -0.147EPA / play-0.059
  • 38.6%Success rate43.2%
  • -0.067EPA / dropback-0.020
  • -0.251EPA / rush-0.114
  • 7.6%Explosive rate8.8%
  • 29.2%Third-down rate40.8%
  • 50.7%Red-zone TD rate53.2%
  • 1.18Points / drive1.40
  • 3.8%Turnover rate3.1%
  • -0.002EPA / play allowed-0.048

Bar length is league percentile, already oriented so longer is better. The saturated side of a lopsided row holds the edge; rows within ~12 points are washed as even.

The rivalry

CIN lead 32–22 since 1999

Meetings average 42.7 points. CIN are 29-24-1 ATS in the series.

Previous meetings
SeasonMatchupScoreWinner
2025 · W18CLE @ CIN20–18CLE
2025 · W1CIN @ CLE17–16CIN
2024 · W16CLE @ CIN6–24CIN
2024 · W7CIN @ CLE21–14CIN
2023 · W18CLE @ CIN14–31CIN
2023 · W1CIN @ CLE3–24CLE
2022 · W14CLE @ CIN10–23CIN
2022 · W8CIN @ CLE13–32CLE

Possession by possession

How it unfolded

Every drive: who had the ball, how far it went, how it ended, and the score as it settled.

Drive-by-drive log
BallStartPlaysYardsResultCLE–CIN
CINQ1 15:0020Turnover6–0
CLEQ1 14:3517Touchdown7–0
CINQ1 14:27379Touchdown7–7
CLEQ1 12:583-1Punt7–7
CINQ1 11:15362Touchdown7–14
CLEQ1 10:07865Field goal10–14
CINQ1 5:14414Turnover10–14
CLEQ1 3:16721Field goal13–14
CINQ2 14:56519Punt13–14
CLEQ2 11:4136Punt13–14
CINQ2 9:47754Touchdown13–21
CLEQ2 6:193-3Punt13–21
CINQ2 4:11521Field goal13–24
CLEQ2 1:17321Turnover13–24
CINQ2 0:19222Field goal13–27
CLEQ2 0:0200End of half13–27
CLEQ3 15:00364Touchdown20–27
CINQ3 13:34372Touchdown20–34
CLEQ3 12:05753Touchdown27–34
CINQ3 8:35758Touchdown27–41
CLEQ3 4:34269Touchdown34–41
CINQ3 3:39942Field goal34–44
CLEQ4 14:15777Touchdown41–44
CINQ4 10:5110Turnover47–44
CLEQ4 10:2211Touchdown48–44
CINQ4 10:22760Touchdown48–51
CLEQ4 6:2941Punt48–51
CINQ4 4:4132Punt48–51
CLEQ4 2:37414Opp touchdown48–58
CLEQ4 1:43767Turnover on downs48–58
CINQ4 0:1200End of half48–58

Box score

Individual performances

Browns

Passing

PlayerC/AttYdsTDINT
Kelly Holcomb30/3941352

Rushing

PlayerCarYdsAvgTD
William Green15755.01
Kelly Holcomb100.00

Bengals

Passing

PlayerC/AttYdsTDINT
Carson Palmer22/2925143

Rushing

PlayerCarYdsAvgTD
Rudi Johnson262027.82
T.J. Houshmandzadeh2178.50
Kenny Watson11515.00
Carson Palmer2105.00
Chad Johnson199.00

Where this game is likely to land

  • Model
  • Smooth (normal)
  • Betting line

Probability of each final margin. Football scoring clusters — the spikes at 3 and 7 are real, and a smooth model misses them.

line +64.0%2.7%7.0%7.5%3.1%4.7%3.0%

Positive margins favour Bengals; negative favour Browns.

Half-point at risk

3.09%

outcomes that flip if the line moves 0.5

Model home win

55.2%

Expected total

42.2est.

Model

Where the number comes from

Each component is additive, in points of expected margin.

  • Team ratings (opponent-adjusted EPA)+2.49
  • Home-field advantage+2.56
  • Quarterback adjustment-2.77
  • Rest differential0.00
  • Expected margin+2.28